Roy Keane says Bruno Fernandes ‘not captaincy material’ after Manchester derby defeat

United were outclassed by Manchester City in a one-sided derby at Old Trafford.
Roy Keane says Bruno Fernandes ‘not captaincy material’ after Manchester derby defeat

By PA Sport Staff

Roy Keane insisted Bruno Fernandes should be stripped of the Manchester United captaincy after they were outclassed by Manchester City in a one-sided derby at Old Trafford.

Erling Haaland struck from the penalty spot after 26 minutes and then headed home shortly after the interval before Phil Foden put an emphatic stamp on a 3-0 victory for Pep Guardiola’s visitors.

While City laid down a marker in their Premier League title defence, United’s defeat was their fifth in just 10 matches this season and left them 11 points adrift of leaders Tottenham.

Assessing what United can do immediately in an attempt to rectify their failings amid a turbulent time for the club both on and off the field, former skipper Keane suggested taking the armband off Fernandes, who assumed the role from out-of-favour defender Harry Maguire ahead of the campaign.

Keane, who captained United from 1997 to 2005 during one of the club’s most successful periods, told Sky Sports: “After today, having watched him again, I would definitely take the captaincy off him.

“One hundred per cent. I know it’s a big decision, they’ve changed the captaincy with Maguire. But Fernandes is not captaincy material.

“I think he’s talented player, no doubt about it, but what I saw today…his whinging, his moaning, his throwing his arms up in the air constantly, it really isn’t acceptable.

“What we saw today, I would take that off him. The manager is capable of doing that. He’s the opposite to what I would want in a captain.”

more Roy Keane articles

The Masters - Final Round Poll: Who is Ireland's greatest sportsperson of the 21st century?
Ruben Amorim urges Roy Keane and other critics to enjoy Bruno Fernandes Ruben Amorim urges Roy Keane and other critics to enjoy Bruno Fernandes
I’m embarrassed for him – Roy Keane slates Kyle Walker for Manchester derby dive I’m embarrassed for him – Roy Keane slates Kyle Walker for Manchester derby dive

More in this section

There’s lots to get better – Thomas Tuchel demands improvement from England There’s lots to get better – Thomas Tuchel demands improvement from England
John Donnelly lifts the cup 8/6/2025 Kilkenny hold off Galway fightback to win sixth Leinster title in a row
Alisson Becker expecting Liverpool to take up contract option Alisson Becker expecting Liverpool to take up contract option

Sponsored Content

Digital advertising in focus at Irish Examiner’s Lunch & Learn event  Digital advertising in focus at Irish Examiner’s Lunch & Learn event 
Experience a burst of culture with Cork Midsummer Festival  Experience a burst of culture with Cork Midsummer Festival 
How to get involved in Bike Week 2025 How to get involved in Bike Week 2025
Us Cookie Policy and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

Add Echolive.ie to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more