Premier League: Everton at risk of more than relegation

Relegation-threatened Everton see them at risk of losing their 69-year run at the top tier of English football. But John Roycroft wonders if there is more at risk for the Toffees than just leaving the top table?
Premier League: Everton at risk of more than relegation

Everton goalkeeper Jordan Pickford (left) and team-mate James Garner at the end of the Premier League match at the King Power Stadium, Leicester. Picture: Mike Egerton/PA Wire.

THERE is never a good time to be relegated but there is a strong argument that if Everton should drop out of the Premier League, the fallout may be more severe than if it happens to any of the fellow struggling clubs around them.

The Merseyside outfit showed their fighting spirit on Monday night by coming from behind to claim an away draw against fellow relegation worriers Leicester City at the King Power Stadium. Yet in typical fashion, the draw probably did little for either side when three-point wins are the only currency for survival. I suppose Everton can at least take a morale-boost from the fight at least. But the reality continues that Sean Dyche's side remain second from bottom with time running out fast.

Everton's Irish international Seamus Coleman leaves the pitch on a stretcher after becoming injured during the Premier League match against Leicester at the King Power Stadium, Leicester. 
Everton's Irish international Seamus Coleman leaves the pitch on a stretcher after becoming injured during the Premier League match against Leicester at the King Power Stadium, Leicester. 

Legacy

History more than most will play on any narrative of an Everton relegation should it happen. Everton have a 69 years run in the top flight at risk and still possess the record for the club with the longest time in top-flight football overall. 120 years of top-tier football has them 11 years ahead of Aston Villa and 12-years above their hated neighbours Liverpool on 108 years in third place. The last time the Toffees were outside of the elites was way back in the 1953 after a three-year spell in the doldrums.

Only Arsenal have a longer uninterrupted spell in the top flight having not been relegated since 1913 returning in 1919 and never relegated since.

If Everton should go down, it will be a radically new experience in comparison to all the sides they are battling with to avoid the drop, who have all experienced the shock of the drop in relatively recent times in their history.

All the other clubs know what to expect from the drop, have culturally become accustomed to life outside the top league. They have cut their budgets to accommodate the drop, should it happen to them, and may well be already planning their strategies for next season on a way of getting back to the Premier League.

Everton probably have never realistically countenanced such an eventuality and would be financially and culturally shocked by having to take the step down a tier. They have no frame of reference or experience of having to deal with such a framework and it must be ed that the last time they experienced this drop, Queen Elizabeth II was not on the throne, and Mount Everest was still to be conquered. Not much institutional memory of that remains at the club.

Costs

Financially, Everton’s payroll is certainly bigger than their fellow relegation strugglers, with maybe the exception being Leicester City, who still have a few high-earners from their title-winning campaign in 2016.

While clubs accustomed to relegation, even expecting the drop, will have cut their financial cloth with the expectation of a return to the Championship, Everton were ploughing finances into new talent and managers in the effort to avoid the drop.

Cuts to these wages, should they be relegated, will see a talent flight and result in any rebuilding having to be done with inferior players making any return all the more difficult.

The current Everton annual wage bill is just over £80m and that would be slashed immediately in the Championship as prize money and incomes become drastically reduced.

A general view of Everton FC's new £500m  stadium under construction at Bramley-Moore Dock in Liverpool. Picture : Peter Byrne/PA Wire.
A general view of Everton FC's new £500m  stadium under construction at Bramley-Moore Dock in Liverpool. Picture : Peter Byrne/PA Wire.

But even that is not the biggest financial worry. The Toffees are in the middle of building their new £500m stadium, down in the Liverpool docks, and having one the most expensive and hardest to repay stadium in the Championship is not a boost Everton will be looking to promote.

Add to all that, the fact that Everton’s combined losses for the past three financial years stand at £305.5m and you have the case that Everton are not only looking over their shoulders in a competitive sense but also in a bailiff sense.

Everton play Brighton, Manchester City, Wolves and Bournemouth in their remaining games, which is far from an easy run-in, and it now looks like going all the way to the very last day of the season. Who would want to be fan?

Everton manager Carlo Ancelotti waves to the fans after the final whistle during the Premier League match at Goodison Park in  2021.
Everton manager Carlo Ancelotti waves to the fans after the final whistle during the Premier League match at Goodison Park in  2021.

Coming

Of course, this did not all happen this season, bad board decisions, poor managerial choices, and hubris over many seasons, (just thinking of players bought at extravagant rates, Carlo Ancelotti mid-season departure, Frank Lampard indecisions), have now all come together at this point where a club with one of the longest and proudest of footballing records in the world are looking down the barrel of the relegation gun.

The road maybe running out for Everton not only for Premier League survival, but even existential survival and no football fan would want to see that happen.

Read More

Premier League: De Bruyne's class always makes City a better prospect 

more Cork Soccer articles

Republic of Ireland Training Session and Media Conference Adam Idah: 'I don't have to stay inside all the time - I'm human'
Brentford
2nd June 2025.
Transfer News Cork's Caoimhín Kelleher buzzing to get going at new club Brentford
Jake O’Brien with Gerson Rodrigues 10/6/2025 Republic of Ireland end their season with a boring draw away to Luxemburg

More in this section

Cork U14 ladies footballers beat Galway after extra time in epic All-Ireland final Cork U14 ladies footballers beat Galway after extra time in epic All-Ireland final
Kerry v Cork - Electric Ireland Munster GAA Football Minor Championship Final Boost for Cork minor footballers as captain Cathal McCarthy wins red card appeal
Limerick v Cork - Munster GAA Hurling Senior Championship Final Damien Cahalane a lucky charm for penalties in Limerick

Sponsored Content

Digital advertising in focus at Irish Examiner’s Lunch & Learn event  Digital advertising in focus at Irish Examiner’s Lunch & Learn event 
Experience a burst of culture with Cork Midsummer Festival  Experience a burst of culture with Cork Midsummer Festival 
How to get involved in Bike Week 2025 How to get involved in Bike Week 2025
Us Cookie Policy and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

Add Echolive.ie to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more